EP21 | Shallow Grave

Nineteen-year-old Kara Nichols vanished on her way to a modeling shoot, her phone going silent in an instant. Nearly a decade later, the truth that finally surfaced exposed a chilling betrayal—and left everyone wondering what justice for Kara truly means.

Nineteen-year-old Dylan Rounds vanished from his remote Utah farm without a word, leaving behind only silence and speculation. What began as a missing-person search soon spiraled into a chilling tale of betrayal, obsession, and unimaginable cruelty.

On a crisp November day in 2014, three friends vanished from Salt Lake City without a trace—fathers, brothers, and sons who never came home. A decade later, the horrifying truth finally surfaced, bringing both cruel answers and unbearable new pain.

Imagine tearing through alleys and knocking on doors in a desperate search for your missing 16-year-old daughter. For Alicia Martinez’s mother, that frantic October weekend in 2010 was only the beginning of a nightmare that ended in betrayal, brutality, and murder.