It was the trial heard around the country: The Black Swan Murder. Beautiful ballerina and former Trump groupie, Ashley Benefield, shot and killed her husband, claiming self-defense. But was it really that innocent? Was Ashley a victim of years of torture, or was she just a drama queen in an echo chamber of her own lies?
see more
Sword and Scale Episode 291+

It was the trial heard around the country: The Black Swan Murder. Beautiful ballerina and former Trump groupie, Ashley Benefield, shot and killed her husband, claiming self-defense. But was it really that innocent? Was Ashley a victim of years of torture, or was she just a drama queen in an echo chamber of her own lies?
See MoreFeatured Episodes
see all episodesWhen 14-year-old Alianna Defreeze didn’t come home from school one January afternoon, her parents knew something terrible had happened. Police would follow clues from video surveillance to find the monster that was responsible for one of the most unjust crimes Cleveland had ever seen.
see moreOn January 11, 2018, a routine house fire revealed something much more sinister. 28-year-old Elisabeth Bell had burned to death on the second floor of her small eastside home in Buffalo. But as investigators pieced together the how, the real mystery remained as to why?
see moreOn Mother’s Day weekend in 2021, a brutal crime shattered an affluent neighborhood in St. Johns, Florida. When 13-year-old Tristyn Bailey was reported missing, the community mobilized, unaware of the dark secrets lurking just beneath the surface. As investigators closed in on a suspect, it became clear that some of the most chilling betrayals came from those closest to home.
see more
Can't get enough Sword and Scale?
Join +PLUS! Starting at just $10 a month you can get access to our bi-weekly +PLUS episodes, early commercial-free releases, a 320kb feed, tons of extra content, and discounts in our store!
Exclusive Content
+PLUS episodes and Premium versionsMerchandise Discounts
Get quality merch at a reduced rate!Member Extras
HQ Premium versions of the shows