EP19 | Second Chances

On a crisp November day in 2014, three friends vanished from Salt Lake City without a trace—fathers, brothers, and sons who never came home. A decade later, the horrifying truth finally surfaced, bringing both cruel answers and unbearable new pain.

Imagine tearing through alleys and knocking on doors in a desperate search for your missing 16-year-old daughter. For Alicia Martinez’s mother, that frantic October weekend in 2010 was only the beginning of a nightmare that ended in betrayal, brutality, and murder.

When two Utah teens vanished just after New Year’s, their silence screamed louder than any fireworks. What followed was a chilling mystery buried beneath the frozen wilderness… until the truth clawed its way to the surface.

In the heart of Nashville, rising musician Kyle Yorlets was gunned down in broad daylight—by a group of kids. The oldest was sixteen. The youngest, just twelve. What led five children to commit such a brutal crime—and what does it say about the world they were growing up in? This is the story no song could ever tell.